-
In September, we learned that consumer prices in the UK rose by 2.2% in the 12 months to August –...
-
Emerging markets experienced a remarkable surge in September, climbing over 7% in dollar terms, marking their strongest month since November...
-
In August, we learned that consumer prices in the UK rose by 2.2% in the 12 months to July –...
-
In March 2024, the FCA concluded a thematic review (TR24/1) into retirement income advice. Interestingly, within this review, they found that...
-
In July, we learned that consumer prices in the UK rose by 2.0% in the 12 months to June –...
-
You will have likely woken up to the news that global stock markets have fallen sharply. This appears to be because...
-
You will have seen that the Bank of England (BoE) cut interest rates by 0.25% today, the first cut since...
-
The world of politics took a surprising turn over the weekend, as we learnt that US President Joe Biden has...
-
It is conventional wisdom that investment decisions are usually informed by an assessment of the investor’s willingness to take risk...
-
In June, we learned that consumer prices in the UK rose by 2.0% in the 12 months to May 2024,...
-
Following the overnight news that Keir Starmer and the Labour Party won a large majority in the UK General Election,...
-
As one may suspect, we are often among the first companies called by an investment business when a fund manager...
-
In May, we learned that consumer prices in the UK rose by 2.3% in the 12 months to April 2024,...
-
Yesterday, it was announced that the UK will hold a general election on July 4th 2024. We can understand how...
-
In April, we learned that consumer prices in the UK rose by 3.2% in the 12 months to March 2024,...
-
You will have likely seen the news on Saturday. On the back of these developments, we noted that equities in...
-
In March, we learned that consumer prices in the UK had risen by 3.4% in the 12 months to February...
-
February saw diverging fortunes in markets, with stocks performing well while fixed income markets were largely down. Within fixed income, it...
-
Chancellor Hunt unveiled this year’s Budget on Wednesday in the House of Commons. Background Since the next UK general election is likely...
-
One of the most common questions we receive from our clients revolves is whether to remain in cash or transition...
-
The “Magnificent Seven” Stocks - Our View and Portfolio Exposure – Fundhouse Adviser Insights6th March 2024The concentration in the S&P 500 of just seven names – Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia and Tesla is...
-
In December, the annual level of UK Consumer Price Inflation rose to 4%, up from 3.9% in November (with a...
-
In November, the annual level of UK Consumer Price Inflation fell to 3.9%, down from 4.6% in October. It is...
-
November saw positive news on inflation – UK CPI data for October fell to 4.6%, a notable drop from 6.7%...
-
On Tuesday, the FCA released a 212-page Policy Statement on Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (SDR) & Investment Labels. These new rules will...
-
On Wednesday, Chancellor Hunt delivered an ‘Autumn Statement’ to give Parliament an economic update and announce new policies – “110...
-
Having seen painful double-digit inflation in late 2022, it was something of a relief in October to see UK inflation...
-
At Fundhouse (UK), we help our clients avoid pitfalls when choosing funds. Fundhouse CIO Joe Wiggins investigates why following the...
-
At Fundhouse, we dig deeper into the data to make better investment decisions for our clients. Have UK equity fund managers...
-
2022 has been an incredibly difficult year for investors. Not only have we seen steep declines in equity markets, but...
-
As a UK citizen, it is certainly worrying that we have our fourth Chancellor and (soon to be) third prime...
-
The UK commercial property market is facing a torrid environment. Not only is the economic outlook bleak; but rising interest...
-
Over the years at Fundhouse (UK), we’ve spoken to dozens of #assetmanagement firms undergoing corporate change. Today, we share insights on...
-
Based on years of observation and bitter, painful experience; here are my thoughts on the ten most significant mistakes made...
-
At Fundhouse (UK), we use our own algorithms to analyse trading patterns, giving our clients greater #investmentclarity about the funds...
-
At Fundhouse (UK), we monitor the fund universe for signs of #liquidity issues, to give our clients better #InvestmentClarity. Today, we...
-
At Fundhouse (UK) we’ve been building a #greenwashing detector to give our clients greater #investmentclarity. We’ve uncovered a number of insights...
-
In today’s blog, we look back at the many meetings that we have had with fund groups discussing ESG. Although...
-
The market has become counterintuitive: in a strongly rising market across almost all asset classes, we find expensive has beaten...
-
As part of our manager research process for a given fund, we will evaluate the corporate entity employing the investment...
-
In this article, we explore whether there is persistency in tactical asset allocation skill, by evaluating the evidence we have...
-
In this article, we discuss how the historic low yields we are seeing in credit markets today does not seem...
Active Asset Allocation: Is It Worth All The Effort?
|
Home » Published: 21st May 2024 This Article was Written by: Rory Maguire and Peter Brunt |
The conscious decision to invest in one asset class over another is probably the most important investment decision we will ever make. By way of example, the following asset class returns were enjoyed by sterling investors over the last 10 years: North American Equities 272%, Chinese Equities 84%, UK Equities 67%, Direct Property 30% and Gilts 7%. The decision to apportion capital between them and others, was non-trivial.
Therefore, it is understandable and rational for professional investors (in this case, fund managers) to invest a lot of time and resources into developing their asset allocation skills.
At Fundhouse, we use our extensive fund research capabilities to assess the skill of fund managers. We often question whether professional investors add value by doing something (asset allocation) rather than nothing (investing without changing their asset allocation).
Our prior assessment
We looked into this question in 2021 (https://www.fundhouse.co.uk/limited-evidence-of-taa-skill/) and found that there was limited evidence of skill in Tactical Asset Allocation (TAA). In 80% of cases, it would have been better to have done nothing, rather than something.
A lot has changed since 2021, such as bond market downturns and US equities strongly outperforming, so we thought that it was a good time to revisit this analysis.
Summary of our assessment, and what was in scope?
Our approach was simple but meaningful:
- We included over 160 multi-asset funds categorised in the IA Mixed Investments 40-85% Shares sector that had at least a five-year track record. Many are run on a 60/40 basis, in spite of the broad sector parameters.
- Next, we compared the sample to two 60/40 benchmarks (rebalanced semi-annually), one with a UK home bias and one without.
- For the 40% bond allocation, we used a global aggregate bond hedged to sterling index.
- For the equity element with a UK home bias, we used a 15% UK, 45% global ex-UK blend.
- For the equity element without a UK home bias, we used a standard global equity index.
What did we find?
Low success rates. Over 10 years to the end of March 2024, less than 15% of 160 multi-asset funds outperformed the fully global benchmark, while less than 20% outperformed the UK-biased benchmark. In short, the outcome is similar to our findings three years ago. In over 80% of cases, it would have been better to have done nothing, rather than something.
Additional assessment
We also looked at monthly five-year rolling returns. Relative to the 60/40 UK-biased composite benchmark, only 20% of multi-asset funds outperformed at least 50% of the time over ten years to 31 March 2024. The numbers were even worse when compared against the composite without a UK bias, dropping to just 10% of multi-asset funds, outperforming at least 50% of the time. Overall, the picture is similar to the 10-year assessment.
We appreciate that we have used two benchmarks that may not be perfectly aligned with the way each fund in the sector is run. But, if asset allocation skill was obvious, this shouldn’t matter over long timeframes. Yet, it wasn’t so long ago that the industry was writing the obituary of the 60/40 fund – the very blend that has continued to outperform them, on average. There will always be reasons why markets are anomalous.
What about other sectors?
We looked at the IA Mixed Investment 40-85% Shares sector in most detail because much was written about how a 60/40 benchmark was no longer sensible. We investigated various other sectors and found similar results.
What would we conclude?
Besides the obvious point that owning a passively run multi-asset fund is probably best, it does throw out the obvious question: why would this happen? There may well be two broad explanations.
The first is that we are wired to have a brake pedal that is bigger than our accelerator – believing that a rustle in the grass was a predator, when it was almost certainly the wind, saved our life. The instinct to err on the side of caution may cause fund managers to reduce risk too soon and add it back too late.
The second relates to the approach. As we have mentioned in our previous blogs, asset allocation in most multi-asset strategies is heavily influenced by macro insights and forecasts. Our research suggests that the odds of getting these forecasts consistently right are very low.
Read our prior findings here.
Speak to the team: mps@fundhouse.co.uk.
Fundhouse is the trading name of Fundhouse Bespoke Limited. Fundhouse provides investment management services to professional clients and does not provide financial advice. Importantly, this note does not represent investment advice and any reader should always speak to their financial adviser before making any investment decisions. Please note that the value of any investment may go down as well as up and you may lose capital when investing and the value of your investments may not always increase. Please ensure that you are comfortable bearing financial losses and that you are comfortable taking a long-term investment view of five years or more.